Food & Drink Menu | Cayuga Lake Creamery

Food & Drink

“We don’t serve fast food. We serve good food as fast as we can.”

Cayuga Lake Creamery Food Drink Board

Counter service is available. Enjoy your meal in our AC informal dining area, out on our sunny deck or picnic down by our pond.

Your food is made when you order. In a hurry? Call ahead and we’ll have it ready for you.

Please note that our kitchen closes 1 hour before our closing time May-October.

Boy Eating Hotdog

Fried Haddock Sandwich  
1/4 Lb Hamburger or Vegi-Burger  
with cheese add  
with bacon add  
Chicken Sandwich – Crispy, Grilled or Buffalo  
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich  
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich  
Pulled Pork Sandwich  
Garden Side Salad  
Garden Side Salad with Chicken  
Hofmann Hot Dog (Red or White)  
Chili Dog  
Cheese Dog  
Chili Cheese Dog  
Grilled Cheese  
Meat Ball Parm  
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks  
Hot-zzarella Cheese Sticks  
Brocolli Cheese Bacon Bites  
Sweet Potato Fries  
French Fries  
Chili Cheese Fries  
Nachos & Cheese  
with Salsa add  
Baby Carrots  
Regular Soda  
Regular Coffee  
Regular Iced Coffee  
Hot Tea  
Bottled Water  
16 oz. Milk  
Hot Chocolate  
Hot Chocolate Float  
Large Soda  
Large Coffee  
Large Iced Coffee  
Regular Iced Tea  
Large Iced Tea