Ice Cream Cakes

Cayuga Lake Creamery Ice Cream Cherry Cake
  • 6 inch Ice Cream Cake – serves 6-8
  • 8 inch Ice Cream Cake – serves 10-12
  • 10 inch Ice Cream Cake – serves 20-24
  • *Call store for additional options such as candies, sauces or fruit fillings; Soy, or Sorbet options or Heart shaped cakes


We are experts in creating beautiful and delicious ice cream cakes, and ice cream cupcakes. These can be personalized especially for your celebration. To order contact Renee at: renee@cayugalakecreamery.com. You can pick up your cake at either of our shops. All cake orders need 48-hour advanced notice.


Top