Skip to Content
Cayuga Lake Creamery
Just another WordPress site
Our Story
In the News
Our Friends
Community
Homemade Flavors
Interlaken
Ice Cream
Food & Drink
Ithaca
Ice Cream
Ice Cream Cakes
Gift Cards
Catering
Contact Us
Join Our Team
Donation Policy
Sitemap
Menu
Our Story
In the News
Our Friends
Community
Homemade Flavors
Interlaken
Ice Cream
Food & Drink
Ithaca
Ice Cream
Ice Cream Cakes
Gift Cards
Catering
Contact Us
Join Our Team
Donation Policy
Sitemap
Search for:
Close Menu
Fluffer Nutter
Our scrumptious peanut butter ice cream with marshmallow swirl.
View all flavors
Top
Vanilla
Chocolate
Coffee/Mocha
Nut
Fruit
Sorbet
Wine Ice Cream/Sorbet
