Food & Drink Menu | Cayuga Lake Creamery

Food & Drink

“We don’t serve fast food. We serve good food as fast as we can.”

Cayuga Lake Creamery Food Drink Board

Counter service is available. Enjoy your meal in our AC informal dining area, out on our sunny deck or picnic down by our pond.

Your food is made when you order. In a hurry? Call ahead and we’ll have it ready for you.

Please note that our kitchen closes 1 hour before our closing time May-October.

Boy Eating Hotdog

Deli Meat Sandwich
Turkey, Ham or Roast Beef
Fried Haddock Sandwich$6.75
1/4 Lb Hamburger or Vegi-Burger$6.00
with cheese add$0.75
with bacon add$0.75
Chicken Sandwich - Crispy, Grilled or Buffalo$5.75
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich$6.25
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich$6.25
Pulled Pork Sandwich$6.50
Garden Side Salad$3.50
Garden Side Salad with Chicken$5.75
Hofmann Hot Dog (Red or White)$4.00
Chili Dog$4.75
Cheese Dog$4.75
Chili Cheese Dog$5.50
Grilled Cheese$3.50
Meat Ball Parm$3.95
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks$6.50
Hot-zzarella Cheese Sticks$7.25
Brocolli Cheese Bacon Bites$4.00
Sweet Potato Fries$4.00
French Fries$2.75
Chili Cheese Fries$4.25
Nachos & Cheese$3.75
with Salsa add$0.75
Baby Carrots$1.75
Regular Soda$1.95
Regular Coffee$1.95
Regular Iced Coffee$1.95
Hot Tea$1.80
Bottled Water$1.30
16 oz. Milk$1.95
Hot Chocolate$1.80
Hot Chocolate Float$5.75
Large Soda$2.35
Large Coffee$2.25
Large Iced Coffee$2.25
Regular Iced Tea$1.80
Large Iced Tea$2.00