Complete List of Flavors | Cayuga Lake Creamery

Homemade Flavors

Our homemade ice cream is made on the premises in small batches for excellent quality control. We start with a 14% butterfat mix from our dairy, Upstate Farms. We then add the finest ingredients available – from down the road and around the world – to create our flavors.

Please note that many flavors are seasonal and not available at all times, but there are always specialties for you to enjoy.

Come in for unlimited sampling!

These Flavor Categories are Available Every Day (flavor may be a variation of the category)

Vanilla
Chocolate
Mocha
Peanut Butter
Coffee
Fruit

Complete List of Flavors (click here to see wine sorbets below)

* Gluten Free Flavors

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Our Current Flavors Outdoor Chalkboard

Banana *

Banana ice cream made with fresh bananas

Banana Nut Fudge

Our fresh banana ice cream with walnuts and fudge swirl

Banoreo

Our fresh banana ice cream with Oreo

Beary Cotton Candy

Cotton Candy flavored ice cream with Gummy Bears®

Black Raspberry*

Made with black raspberry puree

Blue Hawaiian *

Coconut based ice cream with Blue Curacao Liquor

Blueberry *

Blueberry ice cream chockful of blueberries

Deliscious Banana Split Sundae

Blueberry Almond *

Blueberry ice cream with almonds

Blueberry Cheesecake

Cheesecake flavored ice cream with blueberry swirl and graham cracker pieces

Butter Pecan

Delicious buttered pecans in butter pecan ice cream

Butterscotch *

Butterscotch ice cream with butterscotch swirled throughout

Cake Batter Supreme

Made with yellow cake mix and a fudge swirl

Cantaloupe *

Made with locally grown cantaloupes

Cherry Jubilee *

Vanilla ice cream with dark cherry halves and chocolate chunks

Cherry Vanilla *

Vanilla ice cream with lots of maraschino cherry halves

Chilifest Chocolate (Seasonal) *

Chocolate ice cream with chili powder

Chipitty Chocolate

Our chocolate ice cream with chocolate chunks

Chocolate *

A dark chocolate ice cream using the finest Dutch cocoa and dark chocolate

Chocolate Almond *

Our chocolate ice cream with roasted almonds

Chocolate Cheesecake

Chocolate cheesecake flavored ice cream with graham cracker pieces

Chocolate Chunk *

Vanilla ice cream with chocolate chunks

Chocolate Marshmallow *

Our chocolate ice cream with a marshmallow swirl

Chocolate Mint Cookie

Chocolate ice cream with chocolate mint cookies

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel

Chocolate ice cream with swirls of chocolate and peanut butter with delicious peanut butter pretzel balls added throughout

Chocolate Raspberry Cheescake

Cheescake flavored ice cream with raspberry and fudge swirl and graham craker pieces

Cinn-ful *

Cinnamon ice cream with pralines and a caramel swirl

Cinnamon *

ice cream flavored with ground cinnamon

Coconut *

Creamy coconut based ice cream with shredded coconut

Ice Cream with Chocolate Coated Waffle Cone

Coconut Almond Fudge *

Coconut ice cream with almond pieces, chocolate chunks and chocolate fudge swirl

Coffee *

If you’re a coffee lover you will love this strong coffee flavored ice cream with freshly ground coffee “specs” added

Coffee Cup *

A light coffee ice cream with chopped peanut butter cups added throughout

Coffee & Toffee *

A light coffee ice cream with Heath® Candy Bar pieces added throughout

Cookie Dough

Vanilla ice cream with cookie dough pieces and chocolate chunks

Cookies & Cream

Vanilla ice cream with cream filled chocolate cookie

Cotton Candy *

Cotton Candy flavored ice cream with either pink or blue food coloring

Creme Caramel *

Caramel based ice cream with a caramel swirl

Crunchy Grasshopper

Ice cream with Creme de Menthe for flavor and chocolate mint cookie pieces throughout

Dark Cherry Sorbet *

Made with pureed bing cherries

Egg Nog (seasonal)

Egg nog ice cream with nutmeg

Fluffer Nutter *

Our scrumptious peanut butter ice cream with a marshmallow swirl

German Chocolate *

German chocolate based ice cream with German chocolate chunks, coconut and pecan pieces

Gianduia *

Chocolate ice cream with hazelnut pieces and chocolate chunks

Ginger Snap

Our premium ice cream made by juicing fresh ginger root and adding pieces of ginger snap cookies

Good Life Ginger *

Our premium ice cream made by juicing fresh ginger root from Good Life Farm in Interlaken,NY

Green Tea *

Green Tea Flavored ice cream

Grape *

Grape ice cream made with locally grown concord grapes

Hazelnut *

Hazelnut base with chopped hazelnuts

Holiday Cherry Vanilla (seasonal) *

Vanilla ice cream with lots of red and green maraschino cherry halves

Irish Cream *

Vanilla ice cream with Irish Cream liqueur

Itty Bitty PB Pieces *

Vanilla based ice cream with Reese’s Pieces® candies and a peanut butter swirl

Jalapeno Popper (seasonal) *

A cream cheese flavored ice cream with pureed jalapeno peppers and a raspberry habanero pepper sauce swirl

Jittery Snickers® *

Our coffee ice cream with Snickers® candy pieces

Junior Mint®

Mint ice cream (we use white mint) with lots of chocolate chunks and Junior Mint® candies

Kahlua® Almond Fudge *

Our Mocha ice cream with real Kahlua®, almond pieces a fudge swirl

Key Lime Pie

Made with real key lime juice and graham cracker pieces

25 Flavor Contest Winner

Lavender *

Made with organic lavender

Lemon Sorbet *

Made with juice of fresh lemons and lemon zest

Licorice

A black licorice flavored ice cream

Mango *

Made with the finest Mango puree

Maple Bacon *

Maple ice cream using New York State maple syrup and caramelized bacon

Maple Chestnut *

Maple ice cream with roasted chestnuts from Goosewatch Winery

Maple Walnut *

Maple ice cream using New York State maple syrup and walnuts

Mint Chocolate Chunk *

Mint ice cream (we use white mint) with lots of chocolate chunks

Mocha Almond Fudge *

Our mocha ice cream with almond pieces and a fudge swirl

Mocha Chocolate Chunk *

Mocha Ice Cream loaded with chocolate chunks

Mud Pie

Mocha Ice Cream with graham cracker pieces and fudge swirl

Mudslide *

Made with Kahlua®, vodka and Irish Creme Liqueur

No Doze *

Mocha ice cream with pieces of chocolate covered coffee beans

Nut Brown Ale

Beer flavored ice cream made with Ithaca Brewery Nut Brown Ale

Nutty Nut Brown Ale

Nut Brown Ale ice cream with honey roasted peanuts

Orange Pineapple *

An orange pineapple flavored ice cream with a pineapple swirl

Orange Sorbet *

Made with Orange juice and orange zest

Passionate Peanut Butter Cup *

Peanut butter ice cream with Reese’s® peanut butter cup pieces, crushed peanuts and a fudge/peanut butter swirl

Peach Cobbler

Made with real peaches and graham cracker pieces

Peachy Keen *

Made with real peaches

Peppermint Candy (seasonal) *

Peppermint ice cream with red and green peppermint candies

Pina Colada Sorbet

Coconut flavored sorbet with pieces of pineapple

Pistachio *

Pistachio flavored ice cream with no artificial coloring, and loads of pistachio pieces

Pralines & Cream

Delicious candy coated pecans in a butter pecan ice cream base with a caramel swirl

Pumpkin *

Taste’s just like mom’s pumpkin pie

Pumpkin Cheesecake

Taste’s just like mom’s pumpkin pie

Purple Cow *

Black raspberry ice cream with chocolate chunks

Red Hot® Mama *

Cinnamon ice cream with crushed Red Hot® candies

Red Raspberry *

Made with real red raspberries

Red, White & Blueberry (seasonal) *

Vanilla ice cream with a strawberry and blueberry swirl

Rum Raison Ice Cream in Waffle Cone

Rocky Road *

Our rich chocolate ice cream with almonds, mini marshmallows and a marshmallow swirl

Rum Raisin *

Ice cream with rum soaked golden raisins

S’ mores

Vanilla ice cream with mini marshmallows, chocolate chunks, graham cracker pieces plus fudge and marshmallow swirls

Sea Salt Caramel *

Caramel base ice cream with a caramel swirl and sea salt

Snickers® *

Vanilla ice cream with Snickers®, chocolate chunks, crushed peanuts and caramel swirled throughout

Spiced Apple *

Tastes like apple pie

Strawberrry *

Strawberry ice cream with pieces of strawberries

Strawberry Cheesecake

Cheesecake flavored ice cream with strawberry swirl and graham cracker pieces

Strawberry Shortbread

Vanilla based ice cream with pieces of shortbread cookies and a strawberry swirl

The O.C. *

Our chocolate ice cream with orange juice, Triple-Sec®, and orange zest

Tiger Strips *

Orange Flavored ice cream with a fudge swirl

Tiramisu

Just like the dessert!! Espresso based ice cream with Marsala wine soaked Lady Fingers and chocolate chunks

Ultimate Fudge Brownie

Chocolate ice cream with homemade brownie pieces, chocolate chunks and fudge swirled throughout

Vanilla Bean *

We use the finest Madagascar vanilla and vanilla “specs” to make this awesome flavor

Vanilla Fudge *

Our vanilla ice cream with a fudge swirl

Vanilla Malt w/ Whoppers® *

Vanilla ice cream with malt powder and whoppers®

Watermelon Sorbet *

A very refreshing flavor made with fresh watermelon

WCRT *

White chocolate ice cream with white chocolate chunks and red raspberry swirled throughout

White Gold

Vanilla ice cream with cookie dough pieces, white chocolate chunks and caramel swirled throughout

White Out *

Vanilla ice cream with white chocolate chunks

White Russian (seasonal)

If you like the drink you’re sure to like this flavor made with real Vodka and Kahlua, and white chocolate chunks

Wine Sorbets

Americana Vineyard Barn Raising Red Dark Cherry Sorbet *

Wine Sorbet Outdoor Chalkboard

Americana Vineyard Sweet Rosie Strawberry Sorbet *

Buttonwood Grove Winery Reisling Orange Sorbet *

Buttonwood Grove Winery Blackberry Briar Blackberry Sorbet *

Cayuga Ridge Estate Winery Cranberry Essence Orange Sorbet *

Cobblestone Farm Winery Merlot Dark Cherry Sorbet *

Goose Watch Winery Strawberry Splendor Strawberry Sorbet *

Goose Watch Winery Melody Lemon Sorbet *

Lucas Vineyard Riesling Orange Sorbet *

Montezuma Winery Cranberry Bog Orange Sorbet *

Montezuma Winery Northern Harrier Dark Cherry Sorbet *

Sheldrake Point Vineyard Summer Blush Chocolate Ice Cream *

Sheldrake Point Vineyard Reisling Raspberry Sorbet *

Six Mile Creek Vineyard Dolce Vita Raspberry Sorbet *

Swedish Hill Vineyard Doobie Blues Orange Sorbet *

King Ferry Winery Merlot Raspberry Sorbet *

King Ferry Winery Mystère Raspberry Sorbet *