Contact the Creamery | Cayuga Lake Creamery

Contact the Creamery

Phone: 607-532-9492
Fax: 607-532-9492 (Please call before faxing)
Address: 8421 State Route 89
Interlaken, NY 14847

General Information:

The "Creamery Express" at Cayuga Lake Creamery

If you are interested in becoming a part of the Cayuga Lake Creamery team, fill out and send in our employment application. You may return the application by mail to our address above or bring it into the Creamery.

29 Responses to “Contact the Creamery”

  1. Julie Witter says:

    I have a daughter with an egg allergy and have been trying to find a place in the Ithaca area that serves egg-free ice cream. Does your ice cream contain egg? Thanks!

  2. Claire Crittenden says:

    We were in a few days ago to pick up a Hand Packed Seneca Salt Carmel quart. When we got home we were disappointed to find we got the lighter weight regular. I’m not sure if I can find my receipt but the girl who weighted on us has some sort of cast on her foot.By the way, though a very nice young lady, she was pretty flighty. Forgot to ring us up and had to be reminded.

  3. Sharlyn Sheldon says:

    Hello – I was reading through some of your comments and there were a few that suggested you could bring ice cream to an event. My fiancee and I are getting married next June 2016 at Wagner Vineyards in Lodi, NY and we were wondering if this something you guys were interested in. We are planning to have between 100-115 people. Please email me back with all information you can give me at this time. We are very excited at this possible opportunity. Thank you so much!

  4. Ken Braun says:

    Hi Jeff Kostick, I just sent a LinkedIn friend request to you. Bothe my daughter Karen and I went to Cornell. During my daughter’s time in Ithaca, my wife and I would visit her from the Chicago area, a lot. Almost every time we did, we made a trip from the campus to get your ice cream. It was great and we had such good times there. our daughter has been gone since 2008, so we do not get back there now very much. We miss you guys and your ice creams! Best if luck, Ken Braun

  5. Jill says:

    Is there any way for me to order an eGift card for a family member’s birthday who loves your ice cream?

  6. The Scoop on Scoops says:

    We love Cayuga Creamery! Check it out on our ice cream blog!

  7. The Scoop on Scoops says:

    We love Cayuga Creamery!
    Check it out on our ice cream blog!

  8. Alice says:

    I LOVE Cayuga Creamery. We rented a cottage near there last summer and went every night. Our cottage starting tomorrow is .76 miles from the Creamery! I have a question – do you have wifi in the creamery? We have some on-line things we must do while on vacation…

  9. Bret says:

    Was glad to see you list which flavors are gluten free until I noticed you list Vanilla Malt w/ Whoppers was marked gluten free. Whoppers are not gluten free so any ice cream containing them cannot be gluten free.

  10. Tina says:

    what sweeteners do you use in the sugar free /fat free red raspberry ice cream?

  11. scott wilkinson says:

    I would like to know if you wholesale your wine sorbets and if not where can I get them. and how much do you charge. 845-728-7275

  12. Donald e Aubrecht says:

    Jeff, There are going to be two yogurt plants in Batavia. Alpina Foods, $18 M is open. Pepsico and Muller will open Muller Quaker Dairy LLC $206 M next year. Both to be in the Genessee Valley Agri-Business Park.

  13. Susan Tepfer says:

    We had your ice cream cart at my daughter Ashley’s wedding at Seneca Lake in Geneva in July and I have heard nothing but wonderful comments from our guests. Not only was the ice cream delicious, but your service was wonderful. We just want to thank you for a fantastic job! You made Ashley’s wedding day even more special.

  14. Jeff says:

    I am sorry that you were disappointed by not being able to get our Maple Bacon ice cream, however the main page clearly states that Maple Bacon is a featured “Breakfast” flavor and breakfast is served between 8-11 am on Saturday and Sunday. Also our ice cream flavors page states that many flavors are seasonal and are not available at all times. Again we are very sorry that you were disappointed by not being able to get the flavor that you had wanted.

  15. Rebecca Hoops says:

    Was extremely disappointed to visit and bring 2 carloads of friends to try your maple bacon ice cream only to be told it was only available for breakfast. I mentioned to the clerk that it should state this on the website and he acted shocked that it wasn’t. That was this past Saturday…it still doesn’t show that. What a pity. I am really intrigued by the flavor but will not be returning.

  16. Jeff says:

    Nice write up. Thank you for letting us know.

  17. MKS says:

    Not sure if you’d seen this, thought it was cool.

  18. Caitlin Lippincott says:

    Hi. I’m looking for the contact email of the person in charge of events. We’ve booked an icecream cart for my wedding on Sunday Sept 2nd (contract under the same Sue Kibbe). There are details which need to be forwarded to this person.
    Please let me know whom I should contact.

  19. Mary Joslyn says:

    Just a reminder to put us on your “where’s the cart” page for the weekend of August 18/19. Thanks!

  20. Jan says:

    My daughter will be getting married Aug. 12, 2012 at the Esperanza Mansion near Penn Yan on Keuka Lake. She and her fiance don’t want a wedding cake and are considering a gelato bar. They expect to have between 100 and 150 guests. What can you tell us about your catering services? Thanks!

  21. Suzanne DuVall says:

    Do your gift certificates have an expiration date? Can I get one sent to me in time for Fathers Day?

  22. Leslie says:

    Just wondering when your Lavendar Ice Cream will be available. Thanks!

  23. Avi Miner says:

    Hi Jeff and Judy, I tried to send you email at, but I got a bounce back from The message is about a survey Cooperative Extension is conducting about local product purchasing. In other news, although I haven’t sent out an official announcement yet, you can expect to be at the same booth as last year at the Tburg Farmers’ Market.
    Avi Miner

  24. Katy Heine says:

    sent you an e-mail about summer concerts, but it bounced… ? Let’s talk on Monday: 255-8226. Thanks! –Katy Heine

  25. chad sanderson says:

    Interested in having you cater ice cream for a rehearsal dinner June 15th 2012, at the Seneca Lake State Park, from approx. 6-9 pm. Look forward to hearing from you. Thanks!

  26. Amy Dawson says:

    Jeff … I’m wondering if you guys are interested in being a vendor @ the May Day 5K again this year? It is a $50 vendor fee. It is scheduled for Saturday May 12th at 10 a.m. – largely the same as last year – Chicken BBQ, etc.

  27. abram jacobs says:

    Hi, Will we be including the Creamery on the new Finger Lakes Jigsaw Puzzle

  28. Ali says:

    Do you have pumpkin cheesecake right now?

  29. Katie Foster says:

    Hello – my fiance, Jon, and I recently stopped at your shop and loved your ice cream (esp. the Sea Salt Caramel…delicious)!! We are getting married in May at the Fontainebleau Inn in Alpine, NY. We are interested in getting some more information on having an ice cream cart at our reception…maybe even having a specialty “wedding” flavor? We are planning on between 120 to 125 guests. If you could present a quote for us and give us any other pertinent details, we would love to look into this further. Thank you so much!

Leave a Comment/Response


Please enter the CAPTCHA text