Ice Cream Menu | Cayuga Lake Creamery

Ice Cream Menu

Hard Ice Cream or SorbetWine Sorbet/Ice CreamSoft Serve Custard
Kiddie$2.15Kiddie$3.15Kiddie$1.80
1 Scoop$2.751 Scoop$3.75Regular$2.30
2 Scoop$3.352 Scoop$4.35Large$2.80
3 Scoop$3.953 Scoop$4.95Flurry$4.00
Taster's Choice$7.25Ice Cream Sandwich$1.30
Add-Ons
Waffle Cone or Dish$0.75
with Candy or Nuts$1.25
Pretzel Cone$1.25
Gluten Free Cone$0.75
Sprinkles$0.25
Dip Top$0.50
Candy, Nuts or Sauce$0.75
Sundaes and MoreDrinks
1 Scoop$3.75Ice Cream Soda$4.25
2 Scoop$4.75Float$3.95
3 Scoop$5.75Shake$4.75
Brownie Sundae$5.50add Malt$0.80
Seasonal Sundae$5.50
Banana Split$7.50
Cayuga-uga Sundae$11.95
Homemade Pie a la Mode$4.50
Pie from Maude's Treasures Interlaken
Slice of Ice Cream Pizza$2.50
Take Out
Regular Pack Pint$3.99
Regular Pack Quart$5.99
Hand Pack Pint$5.99
Hand Pack Quart$8.99
6 pack Ice Cream Sandwich$6.99
Click to buy our Ice Cream Cakes
Kids Enjoying Ice Cream