Volume 3, Number 2                                                                  December 2010 
As 2010 Draws to a Close We Want To Thank Everyone for Making This Year Our Best Ever!
  • Smith Opera House Medley of Tastes Best Dessert
  • Seneca County Chamber of Commerce Business of the Month - May
  • Selected by USA Today as Best Ice Cream in New York - August 27
New Early Winter Hours
                  Currently we are open 7 days a week 
                      Sunday - Thursday 11am - 7pm
                      Friday & Saturday  11am - 8pm
                      Closed Christmas & New Years

Join Us at Our Holiday Open House

Saturday December 4th!

Santa & Mrs Claus

   Time: 11am-8pm


Gift Basket Drawing

Lots of Sweet Treats to Sample

Fudge, Pumpkin Rolls & Breads from Maude's Treasures

2011 Waterfall Calendars

Gift Cards Available





Holiday Harmonica Music by Harold Bush (1-5pm)

               Supper with Santa & Mrs Claus 5:30 - 6pm 

               $5 for kids under 12 (Includes kids meal & dessert)

               Please RSVP - (607) 532-9492


Where Else Can You Get Our Ice Cream?  
ice creamThe following places scoop our ice cream:

     Palmer Pharmacy - Green Street, Ithaca

     Ithaca Bakery - Triphammer Mall, Ithaca

You can pick up pints at:

     Ithaca Bakery - N. Meadow Street, Ithaca

     Collegetown Bagels - Aurora Street, Ithaca

     Collegetown Bagels - East Hill Plaza, Ithaca

These restaurants serve our ice cream:

     Cafe Dewitt - Dewitt Mall - N Cayuga Street - Ithaca

                                    Crystal Lake Cafe at Americana Winery - Interlaken

                                    Falls Tavern - E Main Street - Trumansburg

                                    Knapp Winery & Vineyard Restaurant - Ernsberger Rd - Romulus

                                    Red Newt Cellars Bistro - Tichenor Rd - Hector

                                    Simply Red Bistro at Sheldrake Point Vineyard - CR 153 - Ovid

                               You can even get our ice delivered within Ithaca and surrounding towns:

                                    Garden Gate Delivery - gardengatedelivery.com for details.

Ice Cream Cakes, Ice Cream Pizzas and Ice Cream Cupcakes Always Available
 Please call ahead when ordering ice cream cakes, ice cream pizzas, ice cream cupcakes or hand-packed pints and quarts and we will have it waiting for you.  Styrofoam coolers and bags of ice are also available. These items are great for upcoming birthday parties, weddings, Super Bowl parties or any other fun gathering you may have.
Gift Cards Available 
Gift card
We have gift cards available.  They are attractive credit card type "refillable" gift cards. You can order these on our online store and we can send them out for you or pick them up at the shop.

In A Hurry, Call Ahead For Take Out!Food

If you need a quick meal or snack, check out our menu on our website.  If you are in a hurry, call ahead and we'll have it ready for you!  Our kitchen closes Sunday - Thursday at 7pm; Friday & Saturday at 8pm.
Become a Fan of Cayuga Lake Creamery on Facebook 
Be among the first to learn about new or returning flavors and places we will be with our cart.
Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Sign up for our Email Newsletter
For Email Newsletters you can trust